A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by McHenry County challenging a new law that will prohibit jails in Illinois from housing ICE detainees and limit local law enforcement from working with immigration agents.
Senate Bill 667 — also called the “Illinois Way Forward Act” — was passed 36-19 in late May.
In early August, Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed SB 667 into law at East Aurora High School. He also signed HB 121, SB 1596 and SB 2665 into law.
The governor’s office said the package of legislation expands “protections for immigrant and refugee communities and further [establishes] Illinois as the most welcoming state in the nation.”
“Throughout my governorship I’ve directed my administration to adopt policies that make Illinois a welcoming state for immigrants, and I’m proud to sign these accountability measures into law to advance our cause,” Pritzker said.
“Every family, every child, every human being deserves to feel safe and secure in the place they call home. I am committed to making sure that value defines what it means to live in Illinois,” he added.
SB 667 says that no law enforcement agency and state or local government may enter into or renew any contract to hold or detain someone for federal immigration violations.
The law will require all law enforcement agencies and governments in the state to terminate their agreement to house ICE detainees by January 1, 2022.
McHenry, Kankakee and Pulaski counties currently have contracts with ICE to house immigrants at their county jails. McHenry County is paid $95 per day per ICE detainee, officials have said.
The law also says that law enforcement agencies cannot provide information to federal immigration agents or transfer any person into their custody.
Law enforcement would also not be able to ask anyone their immigration status.
On September 1, McHenry County State’s Attorney Patrick Kenneally said he filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of McHenry and Kankakee counties challenging the Illinois Way Forward Act.
The suit named Illinois Attorney General Kwame Raoul as the defendant.
“While perhaps proceeding from good intentions, this symbolic law does nothing other than serve as a demonstration of discontent by those in Springfield with current federal immigration policies and will only harm the very immigrants it purports to help,” Kenneally said.
The state’s attorney’s office said most detainees held by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) at the McHenry County Jail previously resided in Illinois, Wisconsin or northwest Indiana.
“The termination of these contracts will not result in the release of detainees. Rather, they will merely be transferred to other ICE facilities as far away as Louisiana,” the state’s attorney’s office said.
Kenneally said the McHenry County Jail is a “preferred provider” of ICE detention because of its safety record and high standards.
“By forcing all ICE detention facilities in Illinois to close, detainees currently held in Illinois may be moved to facilities with less favorable safety standards and more crowding. It is difficult to see how moving detainees away from their families and legal teams to overcrowded facilities in less sympathetic jurisdictions will benefit anyone,” he said.
Kenneally said that the law is “unconstitutional and a clear example of the State of Illinois’ overreach in seeking not only to dictate federal policy, but also that of local government.”
He said that federal law allows counties such as McHenry to contract with the federal government to house federal prisoners.
“Any state law that interferes with federal law or federal contracts is void under both the Supremacy and Contracts Clauses of the United States Constitution,” Kenneally said.
On Monday, U.S. District Court Judge Philip G. Reinhard dismissed the case with prejudice.
“While we are disappointed with the outcome and obviously disagree, we wish to thank Judge Reinhardt for his thoughtful decision,” said Kenneally and McHenry County Sheriff Bill Prim, in a joint statement.
They said they will appeal the decision to the Seventh Circuit United States Court of Appeals.
“The court’s ruling is a blow to local governmental control, as well as the supremacy of the US Constitution, against a clear case of overreach by the General Assembly and Governor Pritzker. Far from helping the immigrant community, the forced Jan. 1 ending of our contract with the federal government to house US Immigration and Customs Enforcement detainees will cause significant hardship on detainees’ families, as well as the taxpayers of McHenry County,” McHenry County Board Chairman Mike Buehler, R-Crystal Lake, said in a statement.
McHenry County has maintained a contract since 2005 with ICE to house a number of federal detainees, the majority of which were due to immigration issues.
Approximately $8 million in revenue per year from the contract is used to offset costs in the McHenry County Jail, the county has said in the past.